Utica, KY Real Estate Market Report – November 2025

Dated: November 5 2025

Views: 25

Utica, KY Real Estate Market Report – November 2025

By John Reynolds, Realtor – RE/MAX Professional Realty Group

🏡 Utica’s Market Shows Stability with Strong Home Values

The latest RPR® Market Activity Report for Utica, Kentucky points to a healthy, balanced housing market. With 2.91 months of inventory, buyers have options while sellers still benefit from steady demand.

💰 Median Prices Holding Strong

  • Median Sold Price: $332,750
  • Median List Price: $315,450 (↓ 1.2% MoM)
  • Median Estimated Property Value: $258,220 (↑ 0.9% YoY)

Utica homeowners continue to see dependable appreciation. Over the last two years, values are up significantly, supported by demand for newer subdivisions and rural acreage close to Owensboro.

⏱ Near-Ask Offers & Realistic Timelines

Homes are selling for an impressive 99.5% of list price (↑ ~3% MoM). The median days on market is 71, giving buyers and sellers realistic time for showings and negotiations without stalling momentum.

📍 Local Highlights

  • Active listings span $209,900 on US-431 up to $399,500 on Red Hill Maxwell Rd.
  • Recent closings across Valley Brook Trace & Autumn Valley Trace range from $225,000–$431,000.
  • Recent RE/MAX PRG sales include 6833 Valley Brook Trce ($372,000) and 6853 Valley Brook Trce ($431,000).

📊 12-Month Market Snapshot

Market MetricCurrentMoMYoY
Median Sold Price$332,750-0.7%+26.5%
Median List Price$315,450-1.2%+21.3%
Median Est. Value$258,220-0.4%+0.9%
Median Days on Market71+11%—
Months of Inventory2.91+1.4%—
Sold-to-List Price99.5%+3.0%—

💡 What It Means for You

For Sellers: Pricing correctly and presenting well can still yield near-asking offers. Updated homes and properties with land are performing especially well.

For Buyers: Selection has improved a touch, but desirable homes under $350K still move fast—be prepared with strong terms and a local expert on your side.

📈 Bottom Line

Utica remains a steady, value-driven market. Whether you’re buying or selling, data-driven strategy and local experience make all the difference—let’s talk about your plan.

Blog author image

John Reynolds

John Reynolds — Your Trusted Realtor in Owensboro, KY With nearly two decades of real estate experience, John Reynolds has built a reputation as one of Owensboro’s most trusted and results-driven....

Latest Blog Posts

Best Owensboro Neighborhoods by Home Price Range: 2026 Buyer’s Guide

Best Owensboro Neighborhoods by Home Price Range: 2026 Buyer’s GuideIf you're thinking about buying a home in Owensboro, Kentucky, one of the first questions you may have is: Which Owensboro

Read More

Are Home Prices Dropping in Owensboro, KY? What Homeowners Need to Know in 2026

Are Home Prices Dropping in Owensboro, KY? What Homeowners Need to Know in 2026If you own a home in Owensboro, Kentucky, you've probably heard plenty of conflicting information about the housing

Read More

Should I Sell My Owensboro Home Now or Wait Until 2027?

Should I Sell My Owensboro Home Now or Wait Until 2027?If you own a home in Owensboro, Kentucky and have been thinking about selling, you may be asking yourself an important question: Should I sell

Read More

Is It a Buyer’s or Seller’s Market in Owensboro, KY? September 2026 Housing Market Update

Is It a Buyer’s or Seller’s Market in Owensboro, KY? September 2026 Housing Market UpdateIf you’re thinking about buying or selling a home in Owensboro, Kentucky, you may be asking

Read More